The ultimate profitability of organic farm varies, however, and
few studies have assessed the long-term potential for such market
premiums. Nevertheless, under the right circumstances the market
returns from organic agriculture can potentially contribute to
local food security by increasing family incomes.
Entering this lucrative market is not easy, however. Farmers
are denied access to developed country organic markets for two
to three years after beginning organic management since such countries
will not certify land and livestock as organic before that time,
arguing that it is necessary for the purging of chemical residues.
In most cases farmers and post-harvest businesses seeking to
sell their products in developed countries must hire an organic
certification organization to annually inspect and confirm that
these farms and businesses adhere to the organic standards established
by various trading partners. The cost for this service varies
in relation to farm size, volume of production, and the efficiency
of the certification organization
B. FARM PRODUCTIVITY
Farmers will probably experience some loss in yields when converting
their operations to organic production. There is a period of time
between the discarding of synthetic inputs and sufficient biological
activity being restored to the land (e.g. growth in beneficial
insect populations, nitrogen fixation from legumes) during which
pest suppression and fertility problems are typical. The degree
of yield loss varies, however, and depends on factors such as
the inherent biological attributes of the farm, farmer expertise,
and the extent to which synthetic inputs were used under the previous
management system. Where soil fertility is low and biological
processes have been seriously disrupted, it may take years to
restore the ecosystem to the point where organic production is
possible. In such cases other sustainable approaches, which allow
judicious use of synthetic chemicals, may be more suitable start-up
solutions. One strategy to survive the difficult transition period
involves converting farms to organic production in partial instalments
so that the entire operation is not at risk.
Most studies find that organic agriculture requires significantly
greater labour input than conventional farms but this is adequately
offset by the input costs of fertilizers and pesticides which
are not required in organic agriculture. This is especially true
in areas of low ecological potential.The diversification of crops
typically found on organic farms, with their various planting
and harvesting schedules, would distribute labour demand more
evenly and help stabilize employment. Land tenure is also critical
to the adoption of organic agriculture. It is highly unlikely
that tenant farmers would invest the necessary labour and sustain
the difficult conversion period without some guarantee of access
to the land in later years when the benefits of organic production
are attainable.
Soil-building rotations need to be designed both from the economic
and the technical points of view - uses must be identified for
all the crop and livestock products produced. As in all agricultural
systems, diversity in production increases income-generating opportunities
and can, as in the case of fruits, supply essential health protecting
minerals and vitamins to the family diet. It also spreads the
risks of failure over a wide range of crops. It is possible that,
even on those farms where organic crop yields are lower than those
produced under systems which use high levels of inputs, the overall
economic yields of the farm will be competitive since organic
systems benefit from market premiums and lowered input costs.
A lack of information is an obstacle to organic conversion. An
important activity of our Company is the running of Competency
centres from which Farmer Field Schools will be organized to fill
this void. Maintenance of model farms and the conduct of seminars,
workshops, demos are having the highest priority in the activities
of the Competency Centres.
C. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND SUSTAINABILITY
The explicit goal of organic agriculture is to
contribute to the enhancement of sustainability. The soil and
water protection and conservation techniques of other forms of
sustainable agriculture used to combat erosion, compaction, soil
salination and other forms of degradation are also evident in
organic farming to a much lesser degree. The use of crop rotations,
organic manure and mulches improves soil structure and encourages
the development of a vigorous population of soil micro-organisms.
Mixed and relay cropping provide a more continuous soil cover
and thus a shorter period when the soil is fully exposed to the
erosive power of the rain, wind and sun. Terracing to conserve
moisture, and soil are used in appropriate situations and particular
attention is paid in irrigated areas to on-farm water management.
Properly managed organic farming reduces or eliminates water pollution
and helps conserve water and soil on the farm (although improper
use of manure can seriously pollute water).
Organic farmers rely on natural pest controls
(e.g. biological control, plants with pest control properties)
rather than synthetic pesticides which, when misused, are known
to kill beneficial organisms (e.g. natural parasites of pests,
bees, earthworms), cause pest resistance, and often pollute water
and land. Reduction in the use of toxic synthetic pesticides,
which the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates to poison
three million people each year, should lead to improved health
of farm families.
Organic farmers aim to make the maximum use of
the recyclable fertility in on-farm crop residues (straws, stovers
and other non-edible parts) either directly as compost and mulch
or through livestock as farmyard manure. Eliminating the use of
synthetic nitrogenous fertilizer greatly lowers the risks of nitrogen
contamination of water. Crop rotation is a widely used method
of fertility maintenance and pest and disease control, which is
used in large- and small-scale farming in both developed and developing
countries, especially under intensification. Fodder legumes are
well-known fertility-building crops and are grown on vast areas
in sub-tropical Asia and in semi-arid regions for the dual purpose
of feeding livestock and adding nitrogen to the farm fertility
cycle. Grain legumes may also produce a reasonable crop without
nitrogenous fertilizer. Leguminous crops in rotations add various
amounts of nitrogen to the overall farm system through biological
fixation; other nitrogen-fixing plants such as Azolla may also
be used.
Biological nitrogen fixation is a powerful technique but it often
requires some addition of minerals to the soil, especially phosphorus.
Most certification programmes restrict the use of mineral fertilizers
which may be necessary to supplement the organic manure produced
on the farm. Natural and organic fertilizers from outside the
farm are used (e.g. rock phosphate, sulphate of potash, guano,
seaweed, slaughterhouse by-products, ground limestone, seaweed,
wood-ash). While most certification programmes prohibit the use
of sewage sludge and night-soil they are still used in some places.
However, sludge may contain many contaminants including heavy
metals which can have a deleterious and cumulative effect on the
soil, while night-soil contains human pathogens and must be carefully
composted before use.
Crop rotations encourage a diversity of food crops, fodder and
under-utilized plants; this, in addition to improving overall
farm production and fertility may assist the on-farm conservation
of plant genetic resources. Integrating livestock into the system
adds income through organic meat, eggs and dairy products, as
well as draught animal power. Tree crops and on-farm forestry
integrated into the system provide shade and windbreaks while
providing food, income, fuel and wood. Integrated agri-aquaculture
may also be found within diverse organic agricultural systems.
Economic objectives are not the only motivation of organic farmers;
their intent is often to optimize land, animal, and plant interactions,
preserve natural nutrient and energy flows, and enhance biodiversity,
all of which contribute to the overall objective of sustainable
agriculture to preserve natural resources and ecosystems for future
generations.